Most Times as a Hall of Fame Finalist

Many people have reached the finalist stage of the selection process multiple times before being inducted. Here are those who made the final ballot the most often:

PlayerFinal BallotsLegends Score
Lynn Swann1437
Carl Eller1349
Paul Hornung1236
Jerry Kramer1143
Tom Mack1123
Willie Wood1046
John Henry Johnson97
Bob Kuechenberg811
Charlie Conerly75
Pete Rozelle8★
Don Maynard817
Jack Youngblood853
John Stallworth89
L.C. Greenwood725
Art Monk820
Ray Guy837
Andre Reed813
John Lynch825
Reggie Wayne717
Torry Holt724
Jim Ringo761
Johnny Robinson725
Al Davis7★
Harry Carson721
Richard Dent726
Don Coryell7★
Dante Lavelli615
Frank Gifford643
Yale Lary645
Willie Davis642
Doug Atkins643
Ron Yary649
Russ Grimm637
Cris Carter636
Tim Brown621
Charles Haley615
Alan Faneca660
Tony Boselli629
Willie Anderson522
Roosevelt "Rosey" Brown557
Len Ford539
Doak Walker525
Fred Biletnikoff517
Buck Buchanan516
Bob Griese528
John Mackey532
Bob Brown552
Charlie Joiner58
Dan Dierdorf539
Dwight Stephenson543
Lester Hayes422
Gary Zimmerman552
Derrick Thomas543
Claude Humphrey525
Paul Tagliabue5★
Jerome Bettis519
Kevin Greene533
Jared Allen525
Darren Woodson420
Dick "Night Train" Lane443
Tony Canadeo420
Jim Taylor437
Clark Shaughnessy3★
Mac Speedie420
Gene Hickerson436
Mike McCormack415
Henry Jordan432
Leroy Kelly436
Larry Little451
Bud Grant4★
Mel Renfro425
Ken Anderson321
George Allen4★
Ken Stabler435
George Young4★
Randy Gradishar426
Dermontti Dawson452
Cortez Kennedy441
Bill Parcells415
Art Modell3★
Will Shields443
Edward DeBartolo4★
Morten Andersen458
Edgerrin James430
Isaac Bruce47
Joe Jacoby323
Richard Seymour443
Zach Thomas447
Jahri Evans341
Duke Slater3★
Joe Schmidt365
Weeb Ewbank315
Gene Lipscomb213
Sam Huff333
Herb Adderley348
Jim Tyrer227
Sonny Jurgensen328
Joe Namath329
Willie Lanier321
Fran Tarkenton326
Len Dawson323
Kellen Winslow338
Mike Haynes352
Paul Krause332
Ozzie Newsome329
Dan Rooney3★
Marv Levy39
Dave Casper340
James Lofton331
Ralph Wilson Jr.3★
Michael Irvin325
Marshall Goldberg2★
Shannon Sharpe346
Roger Craig321
Dick Stanfel342
Aeneas Williams338
Tony Dungy39
Marvin Harrison353
Terrell Davis344
Steve Atwater336
Kurt Warner340
Kevin Mawae350
Ty Law324
Terrell Owens340
Steve Hutchinson353
Tom Flores31
Ralph Hay2★
Mike Holmgren2★
Sam Mills316
Buddy Parker2★
LeRoy Butler339
Ronde Barber335
Patrick Willis347
Devin Hester343
Andre Johnson323
Fred Taylor24
Marshal Yanda245
Terrell Suggs215
Eli Manning220
Bruiser Kinard221
Y.A. Tittle231
Tuffy Leemans218
Norm Van Brocklin235
Bill Hewitt212
Andy Robustelli249
Bill George260
Lou Groza247
Lenny Moore244
George Connor242
Frank Gatski219
Lou Creekmur241
Mike Ditka224
Sid Gillman29
Charley Taylor231
John Madden2★
Larry Csonka226
Tommy McDonald212
Alan Page261
Art Shell239
Ted Hendricks264
Lem Barney232
John Riggins223
Bill Walsh222
Wellington Mara2★
Jackie Smith28
Mike Webster255
Howie Long236
Mike Munchak246
Dan Hampton236
Donnie Shell223
Bob Hayes216
Rayfield Wright242
Cliff Harris236
Roger Wehrli234
Thurman Thomas242
Fred Dean29
Andre Tippett230
Randall McDaniel268
John Randle252
Curtis Martin216
Chris Doleman233
Willie Roaf268
Michael Strahan248
Orlando Pace234
Jimmy Johnson2★
Brian Dawkins247
Drew Pearson233
Art McNally2★
Cliff Branch219
Dick Vermeil2★
Bryant Young227
DeMarcus Ware247
Dwight Freeney240
Antonio Gates238
Eric Allen217
Adam Vinatieri233
Luke Kuechly250