The Best Defensive Linemen of All‑Time

In the Super Bowl Era

Since 1980, there have been 26 Modern-Era Defensive Linemen honored by the Hall of Fame, with an average Legends Score of 45. For a list of other positions, click here.

PlayerPosStatusLegends ScoreAvg/Year
Reggie WhiteLDE986.13
Bruce SmithRDE844.42
Bob LillyRDT765.43
Merlin OlsenRDT724.8
Randy WhiteRDT705
Gino MarchettiDE674.47
Aaron DonaldDTActive625.17
Alan PageRDT614.07
Warren SappRDT574.38
Julius PeppersDE543.18
Jack YoungbloodLDE533.79
John RandleRDE523.71
Joe GreeneLDT513.92
Carl EllerLDE493.06
Andy RobustelliDE493.5
Deacon JonesLDE483.43
Michael StrahanLDE483.2
Alex KarrasLDT463.54
Doug AtkinsLDE432.53
Richard SeymourDT433.58
Willie DavisDE423.5
J.J. WattDEEligible 2028423.5
Cortez KennedyRDT413.73
Kevin WilliamsDTEligible 2021403.08
Dwight FreeneyRDE402.5
Myles GarrettDEActive384.22
Ndamukong SuhDTEligible 2028372.85
Howie LongLDE362.77
Dan HamptonRDT363
Harvey MartinRDEEligible 1989353.18
Cameron HeywardDTActive332.2
Chris DolemanRDE332.2
Geno AtkinsDTEligible 2026333
Jason TaylorRDE332.2
Fletcher CoxDEEligible 2029322.67
Henry JordanRDT322.46
Chris JonesDTActive313.1
T.J. WattDEActive313.44
Cameron JordanDEActive312.07
Calais CampbellDEActive291.61
Lee Roy SelmonRDE293.22
La'Roi GloverRDTEligible 2014292.23
Haloti NgataDTEligible 2024272.08
Bryant YoungLDT271.93
Neil SmithLDEEligible 2006262
Richard DentRDE261.73
Jared AllenDE252.27
L.C. GreenwoodLDEEligible 1987251.92
Claude HumphreyLDE251.79
Keith MillardRDTEligible 1999242.67
Mark GastineauLDEEligible 1996231.92
Gene BritoLDEEligible 1966232.3
Michael Dean PerryRDTEligible 2003222.2
Bob BaumhowerNTEligible 1992222.2
Ray ChildressLDTEligible 2002221.83
Jerry MaysLDEEligible 1976212.1
Houston AntwineDTEligible 1978191.58
Vince WilforkDTEligible 2022191.46
John AbrahamLDEEligible 2020181.2
Steve McMichaelLDT181.2
Dave ButzLDTEligible 1994181.13
Tom SestakDTEligible 1974182.57
Kris JenkinsNTEligible 2016171.7
Gerry PhilbinDEEligible 1979171.7
Gerald McCoyDTEligible 2027171.42
Rich JacksonLDEEligible 1978172.43
Gary JohnsonRDTEligible 1991171.55
Joe KleckoNT171.42
Louie KelcherLDTEligible 1990171.7
Curley CulpNT171.21
Jim KatcavageLDEEligible 1974161.23
Buck BuchananRDT161.23
Justin SmithDEEligible 2020161.14
Roger BrownRDTEligible 1975161.6
Cameron WakeDEEligible 2025161.45
Jamal WilliamsNTEligible 2016161.23
Mario WilliamsRDEEligible 2022151.36
Lyle AlzadoRDEEligible 1991151
Chester McGlocktonRDTEligible 2009151.25
Charles HaleyRDE151.07
Doug EnglishRDTEligible 1991151.36
Elvin BetheaRDE140.88
Ed Too Tall JonesLDEEligible 1995140.88
Simeon RiceRDEEligible 2015141
Wally ChambersRDTEligible 1985142
Michael CarterNTEligible 1998141.56
Charlie JohnsonNTEligible 1990131.63
Bill StanfillRDEEligible 1982131.63
Rosey GrierDTEligible 1972131.08
Fred SmerlasNTEligible 1998130.93
Larry BrooksLDTEligible 1988131.18
Gene LipscombDTEligible 1968131.3
Bob ToneffLDTEligible 1970120.92
Jerome BrownRDTEligible 1997122.4
Albert HaynesworthRDTEligible 2017121.2
Clyde SimmonsRDEEligible 2006120.8
Ted WashingtonLDTEligible 2013120.71
Trevor PryceRDTEligible 2016120.86
Robert QuinnDEEligible 2028110.92
DeForest BucknerDTActive111.1
Tom KeatingDTEligible 1981110.92
Hugh DouglasRDEEligible 2010111.1
John DuttonRDEEligible 1993110.79
Jerry BallNTEligible 2005110.85
Dana StubblefieldRDTEligible 2009111
Maxx CrosbyDEActive111.57
Bob GainLDTEligible 1970110.85
Justin TuckLDEEligible 2021100.91
Mike ReidLDTEligible 1980102
Danielle HunterDEActive100.91
Art StillLDEEligible 1995100.83
Patrick KerneyLDEEligible 2015100.91
Bill GlassRDEEligible 1974100.91
Rulon JonesRDEEligible 1994101.11
Nick BosaDEActive101.43
Darrell RussellRDTEligible 2009101.43
Osi UmenyioraRDEEligible 2020100.83
Charles MannLDEEligible 2000100.83
Bubba SmithLDEEligible 1982101
Tim KrumrieNTEligible 2000100.83
Ron McDoleDEEligible 1984100.56
Jay RatliffNTEligible 202190.82
Dexter LawrenceDTActive91.29
Trey HendricksonDEActive91
Leslie O'NealRDEEligible 200590.64
Fred DeanRDE90.82
Jerry SherkRDTEligible 198790.75
George AndrieRDEEligible 197880.73
Jevon KearseLDEEligible 201580.73
Aaron KampmanLDEEligible 201780.8
Leonard MarshallRDEEligible 200080.67
Bud McFadinLDTEligible 197180.57
Kyle WilliamsNTEligible 202480.62
Jurrell CaseyDTEligible 202680.8
Ordell BraaseRDEEligible 197480.67
Jason Pierre-PaulDEEligible 202980.57
Charlie KruegerRDEEligible 197980.53
Quinnen WilliamsDTActive81.14
DeMarcus LawrenceDEActive80.67
Al BakerRDEEligible 199680.62
Greg TownsendRDEEligible 200380.53
Cleveland ElamRDTEligible 198571.4
Muhammad WilkersonDTEligible 202470.88
William FullerLDEEligible 200470.54
Everson GriffenDEEligible 202770.58
Marcell DareusDTEligible 202570.78
Will AndersonDEActive72.33
Kevin CarterLDEEligible 201470.5
Pat WilliamsLDTEligible 201660.43
Joe NashNTEligible 200260.4
Tommie HarrisRDTEligible 201760.75
Leonard LittleLDEEligible 201560.5
Vic BeasleyEDGEEligible 202661
Doug BettersLDEEligible 199360.6
Brian BurnsDEActive60.86
Dexter ManleyRDEEligible 199760.55
Shaun RogersRDTEligible 201960.46
Darnell DockettRDEEligible 202060.55
Michael SinclairLDEEligible 200860.55
Bob GolicNTEligible 199860.43
Jadeveon ClowneyEDGEActive60.5
Marcus StroudLDTEligible 201660.6
Sam AdamsLDTEligible 201360.43
Alfred WilliamsRDEEligible 200560.67
Jim MarshallRDEEligible 198550.25
Derrick BurgessRDEEligible 201650.5
Shaquil BarrettDEActive50.42
Jack GregoryRDEEligible 198550.38
John HendersonDTEligible 201750.5
Jason BabinDEEligible 202150.42
Damon HarrisonDTEligible 202650.56
Kawann ShortDTEligible 202650.63
Aidan HutchinsonDEActive51.25
Bill MaasNTEligible 199950.5
Aaron SchobelRDEEligible 201550.56
Grady JarrettDTActive50.45
Trent ColeRDEEligible 202250.42
Dontari PoeDTEligible 202650.56
Leonard WilliamsDEActive50.45
Lou MichaelsLDEEligible 197750.36
Bill PickelNTEligible 200050.42
Lee WilliamsLDEEligible 199950.5
Casey HamptonDTEligible 201850.42
Jalen CarterDTActive51.67
Henry ThomasLDTEligible 200650.36